Mayflash F500 Elite vs 8BitDo Arcade Stick: What’s better?

Arcade sticks are like the cool older cousins of regular game controllers. They give you a feel of those old-school arcade machines and are super fun to use, especially if you’re into fighting games. Two big names in this world right now are the Mayflash F500 Elite and the 8BitDo Arcade Stick. But which one’s better? Let’s break it down.

Design and Looks of the Arcade Sticks

Mayflash F500 Elite

May Flash F500 Elite USB Video Game Controller, Compatible with Xbox Series S/X, Xbox One, Switch, PlayStation 4, PC Windows
  • Compatible with Xbox Series S/X, Xbox One, Xbox 360, Switch, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 3,PC Windows, macOS, Raspberry pi, Steam Deck, Android, PS Classic,NEOGEO mini, SEGA MEGA DRIVE mini, SEGA GENESIS mini
  • By using premium quality Sanwa components—9 highly responsive buttons and a precision 4-way joystick,you can reliably strike instantly and surely, game after game, while maintaining peak performance.
  • Supports the headsets to output the background music and online chat on PS4, Xbox One. Supports the Turbo functions.
  • The F500 Elite was built for modding enthusiasts, so the inside of the platform is accessible for further customization,and the joystick as well as buttons can be switched to suit your playstyle.

This one feels like a tank – it’s heavy, solid, and you know it’s made of good stuff just by holding it. It’s got this see-through top, so if you want to slap on some stickers or artwork of your favorite game or anime, it’s gonna look awesome. Plus, the metal body? Super sleek.

New:   The best order to install PC parts

8BitDo Arcade Stick

8Bitdo Arcade Stick for Switch & Windows, Arcade Fight Stick Support Wireless Bluetooth, 2.4G Receiver and Wired Connection
  • Compatible with Switch and Windows.
  • Supports ultimate software – customize button mapping and create macros
  • Dynamic button layout – button mapping changes with mode functionally and visually
  • Ultra-moddable arcade stick – Universal mounting plate supports Sanwa arcade sticks
  • Three ways to connect: Bluetooth, 2.4g and wired USB-C. The included 2.4g receiver has a special hidden compartment to store it safely.

If you’re into the classic old-school vibe, this one’s for you. It looks like something straight out of the ’80s or ’90s, with big buttons and that nostalgic design. It’s made of plastic, but don’t let that fool you. It’s sturdy and feels good to play with.


Buttons and Stuff

Mayflash F500 Elite:
Okay, this is where the F500 Elite shines. It’s got these buttons and joystick made by Sanwa Denshi. If you’re not into arcade stuff, just know – this is like the Rolls Royce of arcade buttons. They’re super responsive, which means when you push them, the action happens instantly on screen. Perfect for those split-second decisions in a game.

8BitDo Arcade Stick:
The buttons here are cool and do their job well, but they’re not as elite as the Sanwa ones on the F500. However, it’s got this cool switch thing that changes how the joystick behaves. So, you get a bit of versatility here, which is neat.

Can I Use It With My Gaming Device?

Mayflash F500 Elite:
This is like the universal remote of arcade sticks. It works with pretty much everything – PS4, Xbox, PC, and even the Switch. You can plug it in with a wire or go wireless if you get an extra adapter.

New:   Let's compare: 8bitdo Ultimate Bluetooth vs Xbox One Controller

8BitDo Arcade Stick:
This one’s super chill with wireless Bluetooth. It’s perfect for the Nintendo Switch and PC, but it can even jam with Raspberry Pi (that’s like a mini computer thing for DIY projects).

Can I Customize Them?

Mayflash F500 Elite:
If you’re the type who loves to tinker and make things your own, you’re gonna love the F500 Elite. You can change its buttons, its joystick, and even its look with your artwork or designs. It’s like a DIY dream.

8BitDo Arcade Stick:
You can switch out buttons and stuff, but not as much as the F500 Elite. But, it’s got software where you can change what each button does, which is pretty cool.

How much do they cost?

Both these sticks are kinda in the mid-range. The Mayflash F500 Elite might be a bit pricier because of those high-end buttons. But prices can change, so always keep an eye out for deals.

Right now, Mayflash F500 Elite costs just shy of $150 on Amazon and 8BitDo Arcade Stick goes for $120.

8Bitdo also does pretty cool hall effect controllers and other gaming accessories.

My verdict

Both these arcade sticks are really good in my opinion. If you want top-notch quality, customization, and something that works with almost anything, the F500 Elite is a solid choice. But if you’re looking for wireless fun, retro looks, and some neat software tricks, the 8BitDo Arcade Stick is a blast. Either way, you’re in for a great time.

Marcus Richardson

I love testing and writing about new tech. I'm also a gamer and an engineer. Check out my Twitter for keyboard stuff.

Leave a Comment